Supreme Court Ruling on Roundup Highlights Legal and Scientific Divide

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 7–2 in the case of Monsanto Co. v. Durnell, determining that the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) preempts state-law failure-to-warn claims when federal pesticide labeling, approved by the EPA, does not include a cancer warning. This decision is expected to shield Bayer, Monsanto’s parent company, from thousands of similar lawsuits nationwide.
The case was brought by John Durnell, a Missouri resident who claimed that over 20 years of using Roundup caused his non-Hodgkin lymphoma. A Missouri jury initially awarded him $1.25 million, a verdict that was upheld by the state appeals court before being reversed by the Supreme Court.
The ruling emphasizes a legal focus on regulatory compliance, contrasting with scientific debates on glyphosate's carcinogenicity. The EPA classifies glyphosate as “not likely to be carcinogenic to humans” when used according to label instructions, while the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) categorized it as “probably carcinogenic to humans” in 2015.
STAT's op-ed highlights the differing interpretations of causation in law and science. While scientific causation examines whether glyphosate can cause cancer, legal causation focuses on whether the EPA mandates a warning based on current regulatory standards.