Study Debunks Advantage of Kicking First in Penalty Shootouts

By Cameron Tate

Recent studies have debunked the common belief that the team kicking first in a penalty shootout has a significant advantage. According to a comprehensive analysis published in the Journal of Economic Psychology, which examined approximately 7,000 soccer shootouts and 74,000 penalty kicks, there is no substantial first-mover advantage.

The study's equivalence testing found no deviation exceeding 1.8 percentage points from a 50% win probability for the team kicking first. This finding is consistent with research by Csató and Petróczy, who analyzed European club competition shootouts from 2000 to 2025 and also found no effect of kicking order on outcomes.

Further supporting this conclusion, research by Arrondel, Duhautois, and Laslier on French cup competitions indicated that psychological factors, such as fear of winning or the pressure to catch up, play a more significant role in determining performance than the order of kicks.

These findings suggest that the perceived advantage of kicking first is largely psychological rather than statistical, challenging long-held assumptions in soccer strategy.