States Urged to Scrutinize Gas Plant Proposals Amid Clean Energy Alternatives

State regulators are being urged to critically assess proposals for new gas plants, as clean energy alternatives become increasingly viable and cost-effective. This call to action was highlighted in an op-ed published by Utility Dive on October 30, 2026, authored by Will Scott of the Environmental Defense Fund and Hudson Kingston of Minnesota’s CURE.
The authors argue that the focus should shift from utilities justifying new gas turbines to proving their necessity, particularly when wind, solar, and battery storage options are available and more economical. This perspective is gaining traction as construction costs for new gas plants have surged by 66% between 2023 and 2025, and utilities proposed 24 GW of new gas capacity in 2025, a significant increase from 2023 levels.
Recent regulatory actions reflect this shift. On September 18, 2026, North Carolina regulators denied Duke Energy's proposal for a 255-MW gas turbine at the Smith Energy Complex, citing uncertainties in load growth and project costs. Similarly, the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission rejected Minnesota Power's gas plant proposal, urging exploration of more cost-effective alternatives.
Additional analysis from Earthjustice and the Better Data Center Project underscores the environmental and health risks associated with gas-heavy power strategies for AI data centers, estimating $5-10 billion annually in health damages from pollution.