Senate Control at Risk as Unwanted Nominees Complicate Midterms

By Marcus Ellison

As the 2026 midterm elections approach, Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) and Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) are facing significant challenges in critical Senate races due to nominees they did not initially support. This situation has left both parties scrambling to maintain or gain control of the Senate.

In Texas, Thune's efforts to prevent Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton from securing the GOP Senate nomination were unsuccessful. The Republican Party is now investing over $329 million in a tight race against Democratic state Rep. James Talarico. Paxton's nomination has turned what should have been a secure seat into a competitive contest, largely due to his controversial record and ethical issues.

In Georgia, the GOP struggled to recruit Gov. Brian Kemp for the Senate race, resulting in Rep. Mike Collins becoming the nominee. Collins has faced difficulties in fundraising against incumbent Sen. Jon Ossoff (D), leading to a retreat of GOP financial support.

Maine presents another challenge for Democrats, where Schumer's preferred candidate, Gov. Janet Mills, did not make it past the primary. Instead, Troy Jackson is running against well-funded incumbent Sen. Susan Collins (R). Collins and her allies have outspent Jackson significantly, with nearly $80 million already deployed.

Michigan's Democratic nominee Abdul El-Sayed narrowly won his primary despite initially strong polling. He now faces former Rep. Mike Rogers in a race that remains within the margin of error, complicating Democratic hopes for a pickup.

In Minnesota, Peggy Flanagan, a progressive candidate who has distanced herself from Schumer, defeated establishment-backed Rep. Angie Craig. However, her race against Republican Michele Tafoya has been moved toward Republicans by the Cook Political Report, indicating a potential shift in voter sentiment.

Further complicating these races are interventions by former senators who are supporting candidates from opposing parties. Joe Manchin is campaigning for Susan Collins in Maine, while Kyrsten Sinema has endorsed Republican Jay Feely in Arizona. Meanwhile, Jeff Flake has backed Jon Ossoff in Georgia.

Despite these challenges, Schumer has managed to secure strong candidates in two red states. Former Gov. Roy Cooper is leading comfortably in North Carolina, and former Sen. Sherrod Brown is running a competitive race in Ohio against Sen. Jon Husted.