Reform UK MP's Appointment as Chair of Welsh Environment Committee Sparks Concerns

By Marcus Ellison

James Evans, a member of Reform UK, has been appointed as the chair of the Welsh climate change, environment, sustainability, and rural affairs committee, the Senedd's primary environmental scrutiny body. This decision has raised concerns among climate campaigners and think tanks about the potential impact on the committee's effectiveness in scrutinizing government actions.

Evans, who defected from the Welsh Conservatives to Reform UK in January 2026, has previously criticized large-scale green energy projects, describing rural Wales as "under attack" from such developments. His party, Reform UK, has a platform that includes scrapping net zero policies and banning new onshore windfarm developments.

Ruth Chambers, a senior fellow at the Green Alliance, warned that Evans' appointment could undermine the committee's role in ministerial scrutiny, given its unique position as the only environmental scrutiny committee in the Senedd. She emphasized the importance of impartial leadership in this context.

In response to the criticism, Evans stated his commitment to being "fair, impartial and evidence-led" as chair, arguing that a diversity of perspectives strengthens scrutiny. He assured that his role would not be to advance a personal agenda but to ensure thorough examination of policies.

The appointment comes amid heightened debates over net-zero policies following recent elections that saw an increase in Reform MPs. Karen Whitfield, director of Wales Environment Link, highlighted the need for vigilance to prevent bias in the committee's inquiries.

Activist Bethan Sayed from Climate Cymru expressed skepticism about Evans' suitability for the role, citing Reform UK's opposition to renewable energy and its record on environmental issues.