Navy's Quiet Firings of Commanders Prompt Congressional Concerns

By Marcus Ellison

The U.S. Navy has recently removed several high-ranking officers without public announcements, a departure from its traditional practice of transparency in such matters. This shift has drawn criticism from members of Congress, who are concerned about the lack of communication.

Among the recent removals was the command triad of the USS South Dakota, a nuclear-powered attack submarine, following an underwater collision last month. The Navy did not notify the House Armed Services Committee about these changes, prompting Democratic Representatives Joe Courtney and Adam Smith to express their frustration in a letter.

Additionally, Cmdr. Caitlin Cunningham, the commander of the USS Michael Murphy, was relieved of duty on September 27, 2026, due to a "loss of confidence," but the Navy did not make a public statement regarding her removal.

Rear Admiral Dr. Brian Monahan, who served as the attending physician to Congress and the Supreme Court for nearly 18 years, also departed following an internal Navy investigation. His removal was not publicly announced.

These actions have raised questions about the Navy's commitment to transparency, particularly given the increasing secrecy surrounding military operations in the Middle East. While there is no legal requirement for the Navy to notify Congress of such removals, it has been an established practice, especially in cases involving significant incidents or command dismissals.